
We've all heard about it, or experienced it ourselves -- a person we know and care about suddenly disappears, and then a week or so later we find out from someone that comes in that so-and-so has passed on.
Every few months this happens in SL, and almost immediately, the first thing I think is "riiiiight." Now in a couple of cases I knew that a person was dying, and we were told that when the time came someone would come in and let us know, and when the end came that's exactly what happened.
Those kind of cases I don't doubt, as there's warning. It's the sudden disappearance, and then the sister or someone coming in to tell us so-and-so died that gets me wondering. Call me cynical, but doubt always creeps in when I hear this. I have no doubt that some number of death notices are real, but I just as well have no doubt that some are not.
The question isn't "do people fake their own deaths in SL or other online words?" That answer is definitely "yes." I've known of a couple cases where the dead person was spotted later on in a new avi but looking and acting the same as before. The correct question is "why would a person fake their own death?" I'd like to offer a few ideas in a non-exhasutive list for why I think some people do in fact fake their deaths:
1) Involvement Level Too High -- some people get extremely involved in world, and suddenly find they are attached to a person or persons they would rather not be with. It may be too hard to just end the relationship(s) -- in fact, they may truly realize that anything short of death is going to have a crazy person IMing them day and night, causing havok,and so feel the only way to extricate themself from that situation is to "die."
It's more tempting to this, IMO, if a person has given some out-of-world contact info, such as emails, plurks, twitters, etc, and knows that the haranguing will not just happen inworld, but all over the Net where they are. I'm not saying this is a good way to deal with such a thing, but it's the most understandable.
2) No Guts -- rather than the person above, who realizes the only "out" is a death notice, this person just has no guts. They want to end their relationship(s), but rather than be honest and deal with the outcome, they feel it's better to just hurt others by faking a death and getting out fast. This person probably already has the alt all ready, and is already creating a new life for themselves when the "death notice" come in.
3) First LIfe Getting Dangerously Close -- some people get involved in SL or other worlds in a very deep, emotional and even intimate way, but their First Life spouse/partner/SO doesn't know anything about it. Suddenly, the person finds their SO is getting more and more curious about what they do for 18 hours a day in the basement and starts asking questions, hovering around the computer, and perhaps starts making demands for information. Suddenly, person knows if he/she doesn't quickly "die" their SL is going to be discovered, so a quick death notice, cancel account, and that's it, safe. For now.
4) Lies Getting Out of Hand -- This is when 600lb guy sitting in mom's basement creates cute female avi, gets inworld, and finds that SL is just so much better than FL. This person tells everyone he's really "Janie" the 110lb coed at Ohio State who is lesbian and into BDSM. In order to seem "convincing" they start adding up lie after lie about themselves -- past relationships, kids, trips to the salon, etc -- to appear more like what they are trying to pass themselves off as. However, after a while the lies start to pile up, they forget what they told to whom, and may be on the verge of being discovered by others that are seeing through the smokescreen. So a quick "death" followed by a new female avi in another part of the world, and problem is "solved".
5) Bored -- some people just get bored with online life, they've done what they wanted to do, been with whom they want to be, and in order to make a quick exit, just "die."
6) Player -- some folks like to lead people on and then hurt them. They'll get people connected to them, and then suddenly do some kind of anti-social thing to hurt them, and skip off laughing to find the next group of suckers. I think this is the minority of "faked deaths," but I'm sure at least some small proportion of them can be attributed to sociopathic people that enjoy the pain they cause.
7) Narcissist -- Another minority type, I usually think of this when a well known person suddenly is claimed to be dead in FL. If you remember the book Tom Sawyer, around in the middle of the book Tom and Huck Finn run away to the island in the middle of the Mississippi and stay there a few weeks, with everyone thinking they are dead. They decide after a while it's time to go back, and arrive just in time for their own funerals, which they watch with keen interest.
I think some people simply like the fuss that's kicked up over their "passing." Unlike the player above, this person doesn't really want to cause hurt, but just loves being in the limelight -- you could tell when they were alive. Now, "dead," they get to watch the blogsphere go nuts over their passing, vigils and rememberance services inworld, and people crying about how wonderful they were. They probably had some other reason to leave, but they went out with a 'bang' and are watching the emotional fallout with the same level of interest that Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn watched their own funerals.
As to what sets my BS Meter off, one thing I can think of is when someone simply comes in and gives the "news," or puts in on a well read blog or elsewhere, saying that "so-and -so just loved you all, and always spoke to me about his/her loves in SL..." Really? This person never mentioned you -- hell, we don't even know his/her real name -- but he/she told you all about us? And he/she just happened to give you the login and passworld to their SL account? I wonder how many people actually give out this info to any FL folks? I'm sure some do, but it's just a bit beyond the pale that "sister Monica" was able to get in and send out a message when she's never been in SL herself...and know exactly who to send it to, for that matter.
Also when it's a rather infamous death, that really gets my BS Meter going. I can understand the sudden heart attack, or car accident, but when nine month pregnant woman in Calcutta is hit by a bus and killed, and the baby dies a few hours later, and no one can find a shred of evidence of this story anywhere...well, that says a lot IMO.
Again, I do believe that some death notifications are real, I just think some percentage (and IMO, a rather percentage) are not. It's too convenient and easy when so-and-so's family member, or friend, or webdesigner suddenly bears the bad news of our loved one's passing. And yes, I do realize that it's important to deal with the grief and pain of the persons inworld, but as a social scientist, I'm trained to look for causes of human behavoir in an empirical way, and I have to say that empirically, a lot of these "Death Notifications" just don't cut the mustard in my book.
OK, call me a cynic and a horrible person, but there's one avi's opinion. And no, I don't plan to "die" if I get flamed for this! :P
-V
Current Location: This side of the grave
Current Mood:
cynical
Leave a comment









